Economic Conditions of Employer is Irrelevant When Determining Reasonable Notice

In Michela v St Thomas Villanova Catholic School       ( 2015 ONCA 801) the Ontario Court of Appeal held that “An employer’s financial circumstances may well be the reason for terminating a contract of employment – the event that gives rise to the employee’s right to reasonable notice. But an employer’s financial circumstances are not relevant to the determination of reasonable notice in a particular case: they justify neither a reduction in the notice period in bad times nor an increase when times are good.”

This case decisively ends the debate over the last 20 years as to the proper meaning to be drawn from a previous  case entitled Bohemier v Storwal International ( 1982 ) 40 O.R. (2d) 264 ( H.C.) . Here is what the Court said about that issue.

“[18] The confusion in this area stems from Bohemier v. Storwal International Inc. (1982), 40 O.R. (2d) 264 (H.C.), cited by the motion judge, at para. 91, to support the proposition that “[u]ncertainty, especially where an employee knows that there are financial concerns, can be a factor in reducing the length of notice that might otherwise be reasonable…” The motion judge quoted the following passage found at p. 268 of Bohemier:

An employee may be dismissed either on reasonable notice or by payment in lieu of notice. The latter alternative is almost invariably selected because, for obvious reasons, it is not helpful to a business to continue to employ a person who has received notice of dismissal. Payment in lieu of notice involves a cost to the employer for which there is no corresponding production or benefit. In my view, there is a need to preserve the ability of an employer to function in an unfavourable economic climate. He must, if he finds it necessary, be able to reduce his work force at a reasonable cost.

[19] However, the key sentence in Bohemier – not quoted by the motion judge – follows on from the passage quoted above, at p. 268:

It seems to me that when employment is unavailable due to general economic conditions, there has to be some limit on the period of notice to be given to discharged employees even if they are unable to secure similar employment within the notice period. [Emphasis added.]

[20] Bohemier does not hold, and this court has never held, that an employer’s financial difficulties justify a reduction in the notice period. It does no more than to hold that difficulty in securing replacement employment should not have the effect of increasing the notice period unreasonably. That is what this court should be taken to have meant when, in its brief endorsement in Bohemier, it said that the lower court judge was right to “tak[e] into account economic factors when considering the case for each of the parties”: (1983), 44 O.R. (2d) 361, at p. 362, leave to appeal to SCC refused, [1984] S.C.C.A. No. 343.

[21] Nevertheless, it is clear that Bohemier has caused some confusion in wrongful dismissal litigation. Most recently, it was relied on in Gristey v. Emke Schaab Climatecare Inc., 2014 ONSC 1798, 2014 C.L.L.C. 210-028, in reducing an employee’s notice period by one-third as a result of the relatively poor state of the market and the financial health of the employer.

[22] It is important to emphasize, then, that an employer’s poor economic circumstances do not justify a reduction of the notice period to which an employee is otherwise entitled having regard to the Bardal factors. See Anderson v. Haakon Industries (Canada) Ltd. (1987), 48 D.L.R. (4th) 235 (B.C.C.A.), at pp. 238-41 (Lambert J.A.), pp. 243-44 (Wallace J.A.); Farquhar v. Butler Bros. Supplies Ltd. (1988), 23 B.C.L.R. (2d) 89 (C.A.), at pp. 92-93; and Sifton v. Wheaton Pontiac Buick GMC (Nanaimo) Ltd., 2010 BCCA 541, 12 B.C.L.R. (5th) 90, at paras. 34-35, 47-50.”

Practitioners of employment law will be pleased that an otherwise uncertain area of the law( determining reasonable notice )  is now a little more certain.

569 thoughts on “Economic Conditions of Employer is Irrelevant When Determining Reasonable Notice”

  1. Pingback: cheap cialis
  2. Pingback: discount cialis
  3. Pingback: Viagra order
  4. Pingback: cialis.com
  5. Pingback: ed meds
  6. Pingback: gnc ed pills
  7. Pingback: cialis generic
  8. Pingback: Cialis in usa
  9. Pingback: online vardenafil
  10. Pingback: order levitra
  11. Pingback: vardenafil 20 mg
  12. Pingback: casinos online
  13. Pingback: sildenafil viagra
  14. Pingback: slot machines
  15. Pingback: online gambling
  16. Pingback: payday advance
  17. Pingback: cialis internet
  18. Pingback: casino su internet
  19. Pingback: slot machine games
  20. Pingback: cialis 5 mg
  21. Pingback: cialis 20
  22. Pingback: cialis 5 mg
  23. Pingback: generic for cialis
  24. Pingback: casino game
  25. Pingback: viagra sample
  26. Pingback: viagra sildenafil
  27. Pingback: generic sildenafil
  28. Pingback: casino slot
  29. Pingback: www.jueriy.com
  30. Pingback: cialis generic
  31. Pingback: Cialis 80mg price
  32. Pingback: sildenafil
  33. Pingback: cheap lasix 100 mg
  34. Pingback: lexapro 5mg pills
  35. Pingback: viagra for sale
  36. Pingback: buy allegra 120mg
  37. Pingback: amaryl 4 mg cheap
  38. Pingback: cialistodo.com
  39. Pingback: viagra in shanghai
  40. Pingback: cialis info
  41. Pingback: atarax 25mg online
  42. Pingback: viagra vs levitra
  43. Pingback: buy viagra online
  44. Pingback: viagra brand 100mg
  45. Pingback: catapres australia
  46. Pingback: ceclor 250mg otc
  47. Pingback: ceftin generic
  48. Pingback: celexa cost
  49. Pingback: buy claritin 10mg
  50. Pingback: rivers casino
  51. Pingback: online gambling
  52. Pingback: buy viagra
  53. Pingback: casino gambling
  54. Pingback: hollywood casino
  55. Pingback: online casinos usa
  56. Pingback: e insurance auto
  57. Pingback: cheap ed pills
  58. Pingback: shelf life viagra
  59. Pingback: safe car insurance
  60. Pingback: cialis miami
  61. Pingback: buy cialis brand
  62. Pingback: best quick loans
  63. Pingback: personal loans mn
  64. Pingback: buy cialis usa
  65. Pingback: levitra viagra
  66. Pingback: viagra 123
  67. Pingback: 50mg viagra
  68. Pingback: viagra canada otc
  69. Pingback: buy cheap essay
  70. Pingback: viagra amazon
  71. Pingback: cost of clomid
  72. Pingback: cialis generic buy
  73. Pingback: clozaril otc
  74. Pingback: combivent pharmacy
  75. Pingback: cialis en espanol
  76. Pingback: coreg pharmacy
  77. Pingback: order cialis 20 mg
  78. Pingback: cialis
  79. Pingback: cozaar pharmacy
  80. Pingback: cheap crestor 5 mg
  81. Pingback: cymbalta 40mg nz
  82. Pingback: thesis editors
  83. Pingback: thesis help online
  84. Pingback: ddavp pills
  85. Pingback: depakote canada
  86. Pingback: diamox cheap
  87. Pingback: differin 15g price
  88. Pingback: Viagra best buy
  89. Pingback: dramamine cost
  90. Pingback: etodolac cheap
  91. Pingback: cheap Prednisone
  92. Pingback: remedies for ed
  93. Pingback: imodium nz
  94. Pingback: viagra samples
  95. Pingback: natural viagra
  96. Pingback: lamisil price
  97. Pingback: levaquin purchase
  98. Pingback: lopid 300 mg cheap
  99. Pingback: luvox 100 mg usa
  100. Pingback: order macrobid
  101. Pingback: Tadora
  102. Pingback: buy micardis
  103. Pingback: Topamax
  104. Pingback: Aciclovir for sale
  105. Pingback: procardia uk
  106. Pingback: viagra prices
  107. Pingback: how to buy proscar
  108. Pingback: generic viagra
  109. Pingback: bactrim antibiotic
  110. Pingback: canadian zyrtec
  111. Pingback: risperdal tablet
  112. Pingback: toprol 100 mg otc
  113. Pingback: valtrex cheap
  114. Pingback: voltaren canada
  115. Pingback: wellbutrin online
  116. Pingback: image source
  117. Pingback: zovirax tablets
  118. Pingback: zyloprim tablets
  119. Pingback: order zyprexa 5mg
  120. Pingback: sildenafil online
  121. Pingback: tadalafil uk
  122. Pingback: order escitalopram
  123. Pingback: olmesartan online
  124. Pingback: clonidine usa
  125. Pingback: cephalexin canada
  126. Pingback: cialis generic
  127. Pingback: clozapine cost
  128. Pingback: generic cialis
  129. Pingback: tolterodine coupon
  130. Pingback: 141generic2Exare
  131. Pingback: order glipizide
  132. Pingback: cleocin price
  133. Pingback: cialis pastillas
  134. Pingback: the cost of cialis
  135. Pingback: cialis 5mg coupon
  136. Pingback: amoxicillin
  137. Pingback: otc albuterol
  138. Pingback: viagra online usa
  139. Pingback: viagra amazon
  140. Pingback: clomid not working
  141. Pingback: propecia pregnancy
  142. Pingback: metformin 2000 mg
  143. Pingback: paxil for pmdd
  144. Pingback: plaquenil dose
  145. Pingback: clomiphene tablets
  146. Pingback: amoxicillin 500mg
  147. Pingback: Zakhar Berkut hd
  148. Pingback: 4569987
  149. Pingback: buy cialis drug
  150. Pingback: news news news
  151. Pingback: psy
  152. Pingback: psy2022
  153. Pingback: projectio-freid
  154. Pingback: kinoteatrzarya.ru
  155. Pingback: topvideos
  156. Pingback: video
  157. Pingback: Ukrainskie-serialy
  158. Pingback: free dating call
  159. Pingback: site
  160. Pingback: best cialis dose
  161. Pingback: top
  162. Pingback: cialis 25mg
  163. Pingback: cialis sale 20mg
  164. Pingback: top ed pills
  165. Pingback: chelovek-iz-90-h
  166. Pingback: podolsk-region.ru
  167. Pingback: blogery_i_dorogi
  168. Pingback: ivermectin 200mg
  169. Pingback: ivermectin 1
  170. Pingback: stromectol usa
  171. Pingback: ed men
  172. Pingback: viagra price
  173. Pingback: cheap cialis 20mg
  174. Pingback: denton viagra
  175. Pingback: ivermectin price
  176. Pingback: plaquenil 800mg
  177. Pingback: norvasc drug card
  178. Pingback: ivermectin cost
  179. Pingback: buy viagra online
  180. Pingback: canadian viagra
  181. Pingback: pharmacy drugs
  182. Pingback: cialis shop
  183. Pingback: is ed reversible
  184. Pingback: cialis europe
  185. Pingback: viagra
  186. Pingback: 1
  187. Pingback: cymbalta vs.prozac
  188. Pingback: sildenafil citrate
  189. Pingback: buy amoxil 500mg
  190. Pingback: clomid treats
  191. Pingback: ivermectin drug
  192. Pingback: sildenafil 50 mg
  193. Pingback: cialis mexico
  194. Pingback: doxycycline 150 mg
  195. Pingback: buy apo prednisone
  196. Pingback: online viagra
  197. Pingback: online doxycycline
  198. Pingback: cialis 5mg cost
  199. Pingback: cialis pills price
  200. Pingback: viagra hong kong
  201. Pingback: tadalafil bnf
  202. Pingback: cialis capsule
  203. Pingback: what causes ed
  204. Pingback: canada ed drugs
  205. Pingback: viagra warnings
  206. Pingback: sildenafil 20mg
  207. Pingback: tamoxifen benefits

Leave a Reply