Handbook Containing Termination Clause not Binding:

In Cheong v Grand Pacific  Travel &Trade, ( 2016 BCSC 1321) Justice Warren held that a Employee Handbook containing a ESA only termination provision was unenforceable for the following reasons:

1) The handbook came into existance after the Plaintiff was hired and no consideration was provided for her giving up her common law right to reasonable notice upon termination.

2) The handbook did not state that it intended to be a contractual agreement.

3) As the handbook provided that the Employer could unilaterally ” repeal, amend , modify add to or delete from the handbook at any time” the Court found that this is inconsistent with a contract as ” It almost goes without saying that a contract cannot be unilaterally varied “.

4) Many of the provisions refer to theft that the Company” may” provide this or that but is not required to do so. The Court commented that ” Such discretionary language is not reflective of a contract document but, rather, a document intended for informational purposes only”.

5) There was no manifest acceptance by the employee, i.e. her signature acknowledging that she was bound by the terms of the handbook. Nor did her silence constitute acceptance.

I find  the third reason the most interesting as almost every employee handbook I have ever read contains such a boilerplate clause. Moreover some handbooks, especially US based ones, contain an express clause stating that” nothing in this handbook is intended to create a contractual relationship”. This is often mixed in with a clause reinterating the American “at will” concept.

It is now open to counsel to argue that these seemingly boilerplate clauses have the effect of making the booklet unenforceable at least in regards to the enforceability of the termination clause.

There is simply no substitute for  clearly setting out in the employment agreement at the time of hiring the termination provisions that the parties agree on. Why employers continue to try to limit their termination obligations in anything other than the proper way always amazes me.


462 thoughts on “Handbook Containing Termination Clause not Binding:”

  1. Pingback: viagra store
  2. Pingback: cheap cialis
  3. Pingback: cialis canada
  4. Pingback: is cialis generic
  5. Pingback: Rx generic viagra
  6. Pingback: Levitra or viagra
  7. Pingback: generic ventolin
  8. Pingback: cialis coupon cvs
  9. Pingback: cialis 20mg price
  10. Pingback: viagra generic
  11. Pingback: viagra generic
  12. Pingback: viagra 100mg
  13. Pingback: male ed pills
  14. Pingback: ed medications
  15. Pingback: www.cialis.com
  16. Pingback: canada pharmacy
  17. Pingback: canada pharmacy
  18. Pingback: cialis visa
  19. Pingback: generic cialis
  20. Pingback: levitra pills
  21. Pingback: online levitra
  22. Pingback: buy levitra
  23. Pingback: cash advance
  24. Pingback: short term loans
  25. Pingback: installment loans
  26. Pingback: viagra 100mg
  27. Pingback: real online casino
  28. Pingback: generic cialis
  29. Pingback: 5 mg cialis
  30. Pingback: cialis 20
  31. Pingback: 5 mg cialis
  32. Pingback: casino slot
  33. Pingback: casinos
  34. Pingback: what is viagra
  35. Pingback: sildenafil citrate
  36. Pingback: tadalafil 5 mg
  37. Pingback: buy propecia
  38. Pingback: buy sildenafil
  39. Pingback: generic sildenafil
  40. Pingback: cialis online usa
  41. Pingback: Viagra 200 mg usa
  42. Pingback: buy sildenafil
  43. Pingback: liquid cialis
  44. Pingback: cheap cialis
  45. Pingback: generic viagra
  46. Pingback: buy viagra
  47. Pingback: Cialis 10 mg cheap
  48. Pingback: viagra
  49. Pingback: Cialis 40mg price
  50. Pingback: canadian pharmacy
  51. Pingback: viagra prices
  52. Pingback: viagra substitute
  53. Pingback: abilify 10mg otc
  54. Pingback: cost of actos 30mg
  55. Pingback: viagra 50mg prices
  56. Pingback: cheap aricept 10mg
  57. Pingback: cheap tadalafil
  58. Pingback: cialis reviews
  59. Pingback: buy avapro 150 mg
  60. Pingback: cialis in ireland
  61. Pingback: cheap viagra
  62. Pingback: ceclor medication
  63. Pingback: ceftin 125mg nz
  64. Pingback: buy viagra online
  65. Pingback: online slots
  66. Pingback: casino real money
  67. Pingback: best casino games
  68. Pingback: generic cialis
  69. Pingback: real casino online
  70. Pingback: casino slots
  71. Pingback: best casino online
  72. Pingback: gap insurance
  73. Pingback: viagra risks
  74. Pingback: generic cialis
  75. Pingback: aig car insurance
  76. Pingback: sildenafil buy
  77. Pingback: Google
  78. Pingback: erie car insurance
  79. Pingback: 5mg cialis
  80. Pingback: usaa car insurance
  81. Pingback: drugs prices
  82. Pingback: buy cialis canada
  83. Pingback: insurance for car
  84. Pingback: rapid payday loans
  85. Pingback: payday loans
  86. Pingback: small quick loans
  87. Pingback: bad credit loans
  88. Pingback: cialis miami
  89. Pingback: Low cost viagra
  90. Pingback: online bitcoin
  91. Pingback: school assignments
  92. Pingback: homework for pre k
  93. Pingback: buy custom essays
  94. Pingback: parrot for sale
  95. Pingback: clonidine uk
  96. Pingback: Brand viagra
  97. Pingback: order colchicine
  98. Pingback: buy an essay
  99. Pingback: generic cialis
  100. Pingback: ACHAT VOITURE
  101. Pingback: cozaar 25 mg usa
  102. Pingback: Buy shatter online
  103. Pingback: cheap viagra
  104. Pingback: thesis phd
  105. Pingback: order viagra uk
  106. Pingback: order ddavp
  107. Pingback: MOLLY (ECSTASY)
  108. Pingback: differin price
  109. Pingback: 우리카지노
  110. Pingback: buy diltiazem 60mg
  111. Pingback: 퍼스트카지노
  112. Pingback: order elavil 50mg
  113. Pingback: buy Amoxil
  114. Pingback: flomax medication
  115. Pingback: geodon purchase
  116. Pingback: jungle-boys
  117. Pingback: cialis coupon
  118. Pingback: imitrex 50mg usa
  119. Pingback: imodium pills
  120. Pingback: see
  121. Pingback: 샌즈카지노
  122. Pingback: 메리트카지노
  123. Pingback: indocin for sale
  124. Pingback: generic pills
  125. Pingback: 코인카지노
  126. Pingback: bookstore near me
  127. Pingback: ethylphenidate buy
  128. Pingback: lopid australia
  129. Pingback: cheap lopressor
  130. Pingback: luvox otc
  131. Pingback: ed meds rx
  132. Pingback: detectives spain
  133. Pingback: buy mestinon 60mg
  134. Pingback: prescription cost
  135. Pingback: mobic medication
  136. Pingback: canada drugs
  137. Pingback: Colospa
  138. Pingback: Lisa Ann Porn
  139. Pingback: Sibil Çetinkaya
  140. Pingback: corporate gift
  141. Pingback: prevacid canada
  142. Pingback: viagra
  143. Pingback: proair inhaler usa
  144. Pingback: protonix usa
  145. Pingback: provigil pharmacy
  146. Pingback: pyridium pills
  147. Pingback: zyrtec pharmacy
  148. Pingback: allegra d 12 hour
  149. Pingback: revatio tablets
  150. Pingback: canadian viagra
  151. Pingback: cheap tenormin
  152. Pingback: valtrex tablets
  153. Pingback: image source
  154. Pingback: zocor 40 mg prices
  155. Pingback: zyprexa 2,5mg otc
  156. Pingback: tadalafil online
  157. Pingback: nytimes
  158. Pingback: norwaytoday
  159. Pingback: glimepiride 4mg uk
  160. Pingback: dutchnews
  161. Pingback: cphpost
  162. Pingback: cost of buspirone
  163. Pingback: aftonbladet
  164. Pingback: spiegel
  165. Pingback: cephalexin generic
  166. Pingback: buy ciprofloxacin
  167. Pingback: postimees
  168. Pingback: cheap clindamycin
  169. Pingback: lemonde
  170. Pingback: gayhub
  171. Pingback: helsinkitimes
  172. Pingback: 1xbet ng
  173. Pingback: icelandreview

Leave a Reply