Sucessor Employer under ESA not the Same as under the Common Law:

In Carpenter v Brains II ( 2015 CarswellOnt 15542) the Employer went through a CCAA reorganization in which a new company bought some of the assets and employed some of the employees of the previous company. Even though under the ESA the new company was a successor to the old ( and thus she had 17 years service ) under the common law test in Sorel v Tomenson Saunders, [1987] 15 BCLR ( 2d) 38 (CA), the implied term of continuous service was offset by the facts in the case, so she only got credit for 6.5 years. Her notice period was 8 months.

Stinson J listed the following factors in deciding that the implied term of continuous service after a asset sale did not apply :

1) the insolvency of the former employer.

2) the application under the CCAA

3) the termination of her employment by the former employer

4) her hiring on a temporary basis by the CRO ( like a trustee in bankruptcy)

5) the termination of her employment by the CRO

6) the purchase of some but not all of the assets of the former employer by the new employer

7) the provisions of a contract with the new employer which purported to limit her termination entitlements to the ESA, even though the judge found that the clause was illegal as it did not provide for benefits upon termination.

8) Even though the plaintiff continued to perform her same functions despite the change of employer, it was obvious that it was not “business as usual”

My only concern with the judges’ reasoning is that, having found that the ESA only termination clause is unenforceable as it violated the ESA by not including benefits, he then resurrects the same clause for another purpose.

The leading case in this area is Machtinger v HOJ ( 1992 1 SCR 986) in which it clearly states a provision that tries to contract out of the ESA is ” null and void”. If something is” null and void “it is as it it did not exist . How then can something that legally does not exist still affect the legal relationship of the parties?

Unfortunately this is not the first  time that judges have taken into account the existence of an null and void provision and drawn from that document some meaning about the true intention of the parties. This is exactly what the SCC told us not to do in Machtinger. In that case the employer was trying to say that even though the contract was illegal, we could still use it as a guide to determine the true intent of the parties. The SCC soundly rejected that theory and said that the illegal clause could have no effect on ousting the implied term of reasonable notice or implying that the notice period should be a modest one.

 

1,230 thoughts on “Sucessor Employer under ESA not the Same as under the Common Law:”

  1. Pingback: cialis discount
  2. Pingback: Viagra approved
  3. Pingback: pills for ed
  4. Pingback: canadian pharmacy
  5. Pingback: cialis visa
  6. Pingback: generic levitra
  7. Pingback: order vardenafil
  8. Pingback: sildenafil 100mg
  9. Pingback: casinos
  10. Pingback: personal loan
  11. Pingback: personal loans
  12. Pingback: viagra pills
  13. Pingback: cialis buy
  14. Pingback: cialis 5 mg
  15. Pingback: cialis internet
  16. Pingback: free viagra
  17. Pingback: slots real money
  18. Pingback: cheap viagra
  19. Pingback: when to buy viagra
  20. Pingback: Viagra 25mg price
  21. Pingback: cialis dose
  22. Pingback: buy Viagra 200 mg
  23. Pingback: buy cialis online
  24. Pingback: buy viagra
  25. Pingback: viagra online
  26. Pingback: rx trust pharm
  27. Pingback: Cialis 60mg cost
  28. Pingback: Cialis 40mg usa
  29. Pingback: buy cialis
  30. Pingback: order lasix 100 mg
  31. Pingback: lexapro 20mg uk
  32. Pingback: viagra cost
  33. Pingback: actos 15mg pills
  34. Pingback: amaryl 2mg tablet
  35. Pingback: cialis generic
  36. Pingback: aricept 5 mg cost
  37. Pingback: viagra directions
  38. Pingback: cialistodo.com
  39. Pingback: cialis young men
  40. Pingback: best viagra prices
  41. Pingback: tadalafil
  42. Pingback: buspar 10mg nz
  43. Pingback: buy cheap viagra
  44. Pingback: cardizem 180 mg nz
  45. Pingback: real viagra sites
  46. Pingback: celexa 10mg uk
  47. Pingback: cipro medication
  48. Pingback: cialis online
  49. Pingback: slot machines
  50. Pingback: casino games
  51. Pingback: casino online
  52. Pingback: ED Pills
  53. Pingback: viagra wikipedia
  54. Pingback: cialis online
  55. Pingback: car insurances
  56. Pingback: cialis 20mg pills
  57. Pingback: cialis online
  58. Pingback: rbc car insurance
  59. Pingback: payday loan help
  60. Pingback: cbd oil
  61. Pingback: buy levitra in uk
  62. Pingback: viagra 4 tablets
  63. Pingback: clonidine uk
  64. Pingback: cialis three way
  65. Pingback: combivent nz
  66. Pingback: coreg 6,25 mg uk
  67. Pingback: cialis
  68. Pingback: compazine 5 mg uk
  69. Pingback: coumadin for sale
  70. Pingback: cialis istanbul
  71. Pingback: cozaar usa
  72. Pingback: thesisbyd.com
  73. Pingback: viagra and women
  74. Pingback: viagra women
  75. Pingback: essay on service
  76. Pingback: cheap dapsone caps
  77. Pingback: ddavp 10mcg canada
  78. Pingback: buy diamox 250mg
  79. Pingback: buy differin 15g
  80. Pingback: cheap diltiazem
  81. Pingback: doxycycline canada
  82. Pingback: dramamine online
  83. Pingback: cheapest elavil
  84. Pingback: flomax price
  85. Pingback: generic Nolvadex
  86. Pingback: buy cialis
  87. Pingback: how to buy imdur
  88. Pingback: cialis buy online
  89. Pingback: imitrex tablets
  90. Pingback: websites
  91. Pingback: indocin prices
  92. Pingback: lopressor tablet
  93. Pingback: luvox 50mg uk
  94. Pingback: meclizine tablet
  95. Pingback: viagra in dublin
  96. Pingback: cheapest mobic
  97. Pingback: Malegra DXT
  98. Pingback: Zovirax
  99. Pingback: motrin medication
  100. Pingback: prevacid prices
  101. Pingback: prilosec 10 mg nz
  102. Pingback: procardia pills
  103. Pingback: cheap viagra
  104. Pingback: proscar otc
  105. Pingback: buy protonix
  106. Pingback: provigil uk
  107. Pingback: pulmicort usa
  108. Pingback: reglan 10 mg otc
  109. Pingback: revatio medication
  110. Pingback: 44329 benadryl
  111. Pingback: robaxin medication
  112. Pingback: rogaine 5% cheap
  113. Pingback: skelaxin nz
  114. Pingback: spiriva 9mcg cost
  115. Pingback: viagra cheap
  116. Pingback: verapamil nz
  117. Pingback: wellbutrin otc
  118. Pingback: Visit Your URL
  119. Pingback: zyloprim australia
  120. Pingback: zyvox 600 mg uk
  121. Pingback: sildenafil generic
  122. Pingback: irbesartan generic
  123. Pingback: dutasteride pills
  124. Pingback: olmesartan cost
  125. Pingback: cialis debit card
  126. Pingback: clozapine pharmacy
  127. Pingback: carvedilol cost
  128. Pingback: tolterodine online
  129. Pingback: phenytoin prices
  130. Pingback: venlafaxine usa
  131. Pingback: permethrin otc
  132. Pingback: 141genericExare
  133. Pingback: 141generic2Exare
  134. Pingback: wmyflljh
  135. Pingback: order tamsulosinmg
  136. Pingback: isosorbide tablets
  137. Pingback: bactrim generic
  138. Pingback: order clindamycin
  139. Pingback: cleocin tablets
  140. Pingback: cost of cialis
  141. Pingback: cialis 20mg usa
  142. Pingback: ivermectin 10 mg
  143. Pingback: ventolin 8g
  144. Pingback: viagra 100mg price
  145. Pingback: iui with clomid
  146. Pingback: zithromax pill
  147. Pingback: does propecia work
  148. Pingback: paxil lethargy
  149. Pingback: levitra pills
  150. Pingback: propecia buy
  151. Pingback: lasix tablet 20 mg
  152. Pingback: ed treatments
  153. Pingback: men's ed pills
  154. Pingback: viagra from canada
  155. Pingback: online drugstore
  156. Pingback: stromectol liquid
  157. Pingback: buy cialis drug
  158. Pingback: denton viagra
  159. Pingback: regcialist.com
  160. Pingback: pills from canada
  161. Pingback: sildenafil coupon
  162. Pingback: cialis 5 mg tablet
  163. Pingback: escitalopram ed
  164. Pingback: viagra sale
  165. Pingback: cost of viagra
  166. Pingback: sildenafil usa
  167. Pingback: canadian viagra
  168. Pingback: viagra alternative
  169. Pingback: female viagra
  170. Pingback: viagra 30 tablet
  171. Pingback: ivermectin tablets
  172. Pingback: a zithramax
  173. Pingback: tadalafil femme
  174. Pingback: viagra otc
  175. Pingback: viagra ohne rezept
  176. Pingback: bestellen viagra
  177. Pingback: viagra connect
  178. Pingback: viagra sildenafil
  179. Pingback: amoxil 250
  180. Pingback: generic for lasix
  181. Pingback: gabapentin 3 mg
  182. Pingback: plaquenil 300
  183. Pingback: priligy 30mg india
  184. Pingback: taking modafinil
  185. Pingback: ivermectin uk buy
  186. Pingback: ventolin tabs 4mg
  187. Pingback: zithromax online
  188. Pingback: furosemide online
  189. Pingback: neurontin 202
  190. Pingback: generic viagra
  191. Pingback: buy chloroquine
  192. Pingback: modafinil order
  193. Pingback: cialis viagra
  194. Pingback: cialis or viagra
  195. Pingback: otc viagra
  196. Pingback: sildenafil
  197. Pingback: walgreens viagra
  198. Pingback: viagra price
  199. Pingback: viagra cialis
  200. Pingback: médicament cialis
  201. Pingback: latisse sale
  202. Pingback: chloroquine online
  203. Pingback: generic latisse
  204. Pingback: nolvadex usa
  205. Pingback: ivermectin tablets
  206. Pingback: cheap cialis india
  207. Pingback: stromectol otc
  208. Pingback: sildenafil viagra
  209. Pingback: what is tadalafil
  210. Pingback: tadalafil cialis
  211. Pingback: sildenafil citrate
  212. Pingback: tadalafil generico
  213. Pingback: monulpiravir
  214. Pingback: ivermectine
  215. Pingback: generic cialis
  216. Pingback: cialis 20mg online
  217. Pingback: viagra near me
  218. Pingback: cost of ivermectin
  219. Pingback: cdc ivermectin
  220. Pingback: buying ivermectin
  221. Pingback: generic cialis
  222. Pingback: lasix tablet 20 mg
  223. Pingback: stromectol ireland
  224. Pingback: tadalafilo
  225. Pingback: bahis siteleri
  226. Pingback: 3lecturer
  227. Pingback: A片
  228. Pingback: Leandro Farland
  229. Pingback: Leandro Farland
  230. Pingback: Lila Lovely
  231. Pingback: MILFCity
  232. Pingback: valentine pillow
  233. Pingback: Click Here
  234. Pingback: Click Here
  235. Pingback: Click Here
  236. Pingback: Click Here
  237. Pingback: Click Here
  238. Pingback: Click Here
  239. Pingback: Click Here
  240. Pingback: Click Here
  241. Pingback: Click Here
  242. Pingback: Click Here
  243. Pingback: Click Here
  244. Pingback: Click Here
  245. Pingback: Click Here
  246. Pingback: Click Here
  247. Pingback: Click Here
  248. Pingback: Click Here
  249. Pingback: Click Here
  250. Pingback: Click Here
  251. Pingback: Click Here
  252. Pingback: Click Here
  253. Pingback: Click Here
  254. Pingback: Click Here
  255. Pingback: Click Here
  256. Pingback: Click Here
  257. Pingback: no code robotics
  258. Pingback: spaceros
  259. Pingback: Click Here
  260. Pingback: Click Here
  261. Pingback: Click Here
  262. Pingback: Click Here
  263. Pingback: Click Here
  264. Pingback: Click Here
  265. Pingback: Click Here
  266. Pingback: Click Here
  267. Pingback: Click Here
  268. Pingback: Click Here
  269. Pingback: Click Here
  270. Pingback: Click Here
  271. Pingback: Click Here
  272. Pingback: Click Here
  273. Pingback: Click Here
  274. Pingback: Click Here
  275. Pingback: Click Here
  276. Pingback: Click Here
  277. Pingback: Click Here
  278. Pingback: Click Here
  279. Pingback: Click Here
  280. Pingback: Click Here
  281. Pingback: Click Here
  282. Pingback: Click Here
  283. Pingback: Click Here
  284. Pingback: Click Here
  285. Pingback: Click Here
  286. Pingback: Click Here
  287. Pingback: Click Here
  288. Pingback: Click Here
  289. Pingback: Click Here
  290. Pingback: Click Here
  291. Pingback: Click Here
  292. Pingback: Click Here
  293. Pingback: Click Here
  294. Pingback: Click Here
  295. Pingback: Click Here
  296. Pingback: Click Here
  297. Pingback: Click Here
  298. Pingback: Click Here
  299. Pingback: Click Here
  300. Pingback: Click Here
  301. Pingback: Click Here
  302. Pingback: Click Here
  303. Pingback: Click Here
  304. Pingback: Click Here
  305. Pingback: Click Here
  306. Pingback: how to start
  307. Pingback: Google reviews
  308. Pingback: 2023 Books
  309. Pingback: tombstones
  310. Pingback: find people
  311. Pingback: census records
  312. Pingback: cemetery location
  313. Pingback: IRA Empire
  314. Pingback: Chirurgie Tunisie
  315. Pingback: fue
  316. Pingback: fue library
  317. Pingback: MBA tuition fees
  318. Pingback: Community impact
  319. Pingback: Seattle University
  320. Pingback: Governance
  321. Pingback: Political Science
  322. Pingback: Rota evaporators
  323. Pingback: Dental emergencies
  324. Pingback: Career Fairs
  325. Pingback: NAQAEE
  326. Pingback: faculty of dental
  327. Pingback: Cultural diversity
  328. Pingback: MBA degree Cairo
  329. Pingback: Academic Advising
  330. Pingback: madridbet
  331. Pingback: madridbet
  332. Pingback: meritking
  333. Pingback: meritking
  334. Pingback: meritking
  335. Pingback: grandpashabet
  336. Pingback: Research projects
  337. Pingback: meritking
  338. Pingback: meritking
  339. Pingback: meritking
  340. Pingback: Code of Conduct
  341. Pingback: Graduate Studies
  342. Pingback: pandemic
  343. Pingback: meritking
  344. Pingback: grandpashabet
  345. Pingback: fuck google
  346. Pingback: pull ups
  347. Pingback: challenge sportif
  348. Pingback: fuck google
  349. Pingback: Fiverr Earn
  350. Pingback: Fiverr Earn
  351. Pingback: Fiverr Earn
  352. Pingback: Fiverr Earn
  353. Pingback: Fiverr Earn
  354. Pingback: Fiverr Earn
  355. Pingback: Fiverr Earn
  356. Pingback: Fiverr Earn
  357. Pingback: Fiverr Earn
  358. Pingback: fiverrearn.com
  359. Pingback: fiverrearn.com
  360. Pingback: fiverrearn.com
  361. Pingback: fiverrearn.com
  362. Pingback: fiverrearn.com
  363. Pingback: fiverrearn.com
  364. Pingback: porn
  365. Pingback: fiverrearn.com
  366. Pingback: child porn
  367. Pingback: glucotrust
  368. Pingback: 3pl Broker
  369. Pingback: liv pure buy
  370. Pingback: fiverrearn.com
  371. Pingback: fiverrearn.com
  372. Pingback: fiverrearn.com
  373. Pingback: french bulldog
  374. Pingback: fiverrearn.com
  375. Pingback: porn
  376. Pingback: cavapoos
  377. Pingback: frenchtons
  378. Pingback: jute vs sisal rug
  379. Pingback: seo in Bahrain
  380. Pingback: Piano Removals
  381. Pingback: isla mahara
  382. Pingback: frenchie doodle
  383. Pingback: tom kings kennel
  384. Pingback: swimsuit
  385. Pingback: porn
  386. Pingback: porn
  387. Pingback: new york clima hoy
  388. Pingback: brindle frenchie
  389. Pingback: Cash for phones
  390. Pingback: child porn
  391. Pingback: best Phone
  392. Pingback: top Samsung phones
  393. Pingback: future university
  394. Pingback: future university
  395. Pingback: future university
  396. Pingback: drip bucket hat
  397. Pingback: what is seo
  398. Pingback: porn
  399. Pingback: Fiverr
  400. Pingback: Fiverr
  401. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  402. Pingback: fue
  403. Pingback: FUE
  404. Pingback: FUE
  405. Pingback: FUE
  406. Pingback: FUE
  407. Pingback: FUE
  408. Pingback: FUE
  409. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  410. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  411. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  412. Pingback: Fiverr.Com
  413. Pingback: Fiverr
  414. Pingback: Fiverr.Com
  415. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  416. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  417. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  418. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  419. Pingback: Coach
  420. Pingback: Media
  421. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  422. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  423. Pingback: partners
  424. Pingback: glucoberry reviews
  425. Pingback: red boost
  426. Pingback: ocuprime official
  427. Pingback: gluco trust
  428. Pingback: Predictions
  429. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  430. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  431. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  432. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  433. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  434. Pingback: viagra 25 mg daily
  435. Pingback: live sex cams
  436. Pingback: live sex cams
  437. Pingback: live sex cams
  438. Pingback: live sex cams
  439. Pingback: live sex cams
  440. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  441. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  442. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  443. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  444. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  445. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  446. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  447. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  448. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  449. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  450. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  451. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  452. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  453. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  454. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  455. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  456. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  457. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  458. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  459. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  460. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  461. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  462. Pingback: serialebi qaerulad
  463. Pingback: Milk
  464. Pingback: Lightroom Presets
  465. Pingback: wix seo expert
  466. Pingback: gold
  467. Pingback: Situs Slot Online
  468. Pingback: Kuliah Termurah
  469. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  470. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  471. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  472. Pingback: FiverrEarn
  473. Pingback: vardenafil dose
  474. Pingback: sikiş
  475. Pingback: lasix 100mg usa
  476. Pingback: furosemide 10 mg
  477. Pingback: generic Zithromax
  478. Pingback: resurge legit
  479. Pingback: androgel usa
  480. Pingback: buy fildena india
  481. Pingback: cenforce price
  482. Pingback: testosterone gel
  483. Pingback: fullersears.com
  484. Pingback: fullersears.com
  485. Pingback: fullersears.com
  486. Pingback: fullersears.com
  487. Pingback: vilitra pills
  488. Pingback: levitra kopen
  489. Pingback: cenforce d review
  490. Pingback: canine probiotics
  491. Pingback: french bulldog buy
  492. Pingback: grandpashabet
  493. Pingback: live sex cams
  494. Pingback: live sex cams
  495. Pingback: live sex cams
  496. Pingback: levitra
  497. Pingback: vilitra 40mg
  498. Pingback: Freeze dried water
  499. Pingback: rare breed-trigger
  500. Pingback: grandpashabet
  501. Pingback: grandpashabet
  502. Pingback: juicios fiscales
  503. Pingback: Litigio fiscal
  504. Pingback: Alienlabs Agent
  505. Pingback: 늑대닷컴
  506. Pingback: Slot online gacor
  507. Pingback: One Peace AMV
  508. Pingback: One Peace AMV
  509. Pingback: nangs sydney
  510. Pingback: superslot
  511. Pingback: allgame
  512. Pingback: 918kiss
  513. Pingback: หวย24
  514. Pingback: Skincare trends
  515. Pingback: pg slot
  516. Pingback: child porn
  517. Pingback: AI Lawyer
  518. Pingback: cybersécurité
  519. Pingback: Raahe Guide
  520. Pingback: Raahe Guide
  521. Pingback: megagame
  522. Pingback: evisa
  523. Pingback: weight loss drops
  524. Pingback: priligy online
  525. Pingback: z pack 250 mg
  526. Pingback: contratar sicario
  527. Pingback: cenforce 150mg
  528. Pingback: buy levitra
  529. Pingback: itsMasum.Com
  530. Pingback: itsMasum.Com
  531. Pingback: itsMasum.Com
  532. Pingback: itsMasum.Com
  533. Pingback: itsMasum.Com
  534. Pingback: here
  535. Pingback: website
  536. Pingback: Cenforce 100mg uk
  537. Pingback: talktostranger
  538. Pingback: clomid for sale
  539. Pingback: itsmasum.com
  540. Pingback: itsmasum.com
  541. Pingback: itsmasum.com
  542. Pingback: itsmasum.com
  543. Pingback: child porn
  544. Pingback: clomid cost
  545. Pingback: cenforce sprzedam
  546. Pingback: vidalista 5mg
  547. Pingback: super vidalista
  548. Pingback: cenforce tablets
  549. Pingback: anal porn
  550. Pingback: cost clomid
  551. Pingback: joker gaming
  552. Pingback: priligy 30mg
  553. Pingback: whitecollar jobs
  554. Pingback: houston jobs
  555. Pingback: gulf jobs central
  556. Pingback: minneapolis jobs
  557. Pingback: dallas jobs
  558. Pingback: dipocsitin
  559. Pingback: poxet 30 mg price
  560. Pingback: buy kamagra
  561. Pingback: vidalista 60
  562. Pingback: vidalista 60
  563. Pingback: advairhfa
  564. Pingback: buy advair diskus
  565. Pingback: buy advair diskus
  566. Pingback: grandpashabet
  567. Pingback: cenforce 25
  568. Pingback: buy kamagra
  569. Pingback: vidalista 40
  570. Pingback: ventolin generic
  571. Pingback: price of levitra
  572. Pingback: child porn
  573. Pingback: child porn
  574. Pingback: child porn
  575. Pingback: fildena double 200
  576. Pingback: tadalafil 5mg
  577. Pingback: seroflo inhaler
  578. Pingback: sildenafil 50mg uk
  579. Pingback: free cam girls
  580. Pingback: Kampus Islami
  581. Pingback: spinco
  582. Pingback: vidalista
  583. Pingback: animal porn
  584. Pingback: 918kiss
  585. Pingback: Sildenafil pills
  586. Pingback: buspin
  587. Pingback: buy Cenforce sale
  588. Pingback: xenical for sale

Leave a Reply