Waiver and Severability Clause Cures All Defects in Employment Contract

In Oudin v Le Centre Francophone de Toronto, 2015 ONSC 6494 ( Can LII) , Justice Sean Dunphy of the Ontario Supreme Court was faced with a contract that limited the the employees’ rights on termination to the minimum requirements of the Employment Standards Act        ( ESA) . The plaintiff attacked the clause on various grounds claiming that parts of the clause were void as they contradicted the ESA and that other parts were ambiguous.

The termination provision contained the following clause ( as translated from French in the judgement ):

12. Waiver and Severability
12.2 If any of the provisions of the present agreement is invalid or unable to be performed by virtue of any law, regulation, order or any other requirement or other principle of law, this modality shall in such case be considered to be modified or nullified, but only to the extent necessary to comply with the statute, regulation, order, legal requirement or principle and the other dispositions of the present agreement shall remain in force.

Dunphy J. used this clause to in essence fix up the void provisions of the termination clause and rewrite them so as to be in compliance with the minimum provisions of the ESA. Here is his reasoning:

39] The plaintiff relies upon the decision of the Supreme Court of Canada in Machtinger (supra). In Machtinger (supra), whether through deliberate action or accidental slip, it was common ground that provisions of the contract had the effect of providing a lower standard than that prescribed by the ESA. The issue in Machtinger (supra) was whether the court could have regard to the admittedly invalid termination provisions of the employment contract in determining what level of reasonable notice should be implied in construing the contract. Iacobucci J. delivered the judgment of the majority and held that if the clause is void for one purpose, it cannot be looked at for another where there was no evidence as to what the intention of the parties would be in the event the clause was found to be void.

[40] That is simply not the case here. The parties have explicitly spelled out what they intend to do in the event any part of the contract is found to be unenforceable. In s. 12(2) the parties have provided that “[i]f any of the provisions of the present agreement is invalid or unable to be performed by virtue of any law, regulation…this modality shall in such case be considered to be modified or nullified, but only to the extent necessary to comply with the statute, regulation, order, legal requirement or principle and the other dispositions of the present agreement shall remain in force” [translation].

[41] Section 4 contains a precise list of reasons (“motifs”) for which immediate termination of the employment relationship without notice is authorized. Among the reasons listed was “continuing incapacity considered permanent”. That particular reason for immediate termination is invalid. The excision of the offending reason from the list does no violence to the integrity of the remainder of s. 4 which contains a list of other unrelated grounds for termination. It is significant that s 12(2) does not direct the court to do anything as clumsy as deleting the entire section or clause of the employment agreement. Rather, it directs that the “modality” be modified or nullified to the extent necessary.

[42] I conclude that section 12(2) directs that section 4 must be modified to remove the reference to permanent disability from the list of reasons (“motifs”) in s. 4. Removing that reason alone is the minimum extent necessary to give effect to s. 5(1) of the ESA and can be simply and logically done while introducing neither ambiguity nor uncertainty in the remainder of the clause as so modified. That is precisely what s. 12(2) directs be done in plain and simple language. There is no reason to disregard the express direction of the parties as contained in s. 12(2).

As read this judgement, as long as an employment contract contained this savings clause, the remaining parts of the contract could violate as many statutory provisions as they want because the Court would simply rewrite the contract so as to bring it into compliance with the offended statute.

Imagine  a contract that had the above mentioned savings clause but also contained the following provisions :

1. This is a “at will ” contract and therefore the Employer can terminate this contract without any notice or pay in lieu of notice.

2. Overtime will be paid only after 75 hours per week.

3. No parental leave is allowed.

4. The Employer has the right at any time to require you to undergo a lie detector test .

5. If you become disabled for more than 5 days, you agree to immediately resign your employment.

Applying the reasoning of this case, the employment contract would be completely rewritten by the Court as follows:

1. Your only entitlement upon termination is as set out in the ESA. You are not entitled to reasonable notice.

2. Overtime will be paid after 44 hours.

3. Parental leave under the ESA is permitted.

4. The Employer cannot ask you to take a lie detector test.

5. If you are disabled for 5 days, we will not demand that you resign.

Needless to say that would be absurd, but apparently quite lawful, according to the logic of this case.

This decision fails to take into account the realities of the workplace. It assumes that employees are so highly educated in employment law  that they would know exactly which provisions of the contract breach the Employment Standards Act, 2000 ( and its many regs) the Labour Relations Act, the Occupational Health and Safety Act, the Workplace Safety and Insurance Act, the Human Rights Code, the Pay Equity Act, the Accessibility for Ontarians  with Disabilities Act, 2005. Moreover the employee would have to have a good understanding of Canadian constitutional law as well because he or she would first have to determine if their potential employer was covered by provincial or federal employment law . If covered by federal law, the above list of provincial statutes would be largely substituted by their federal counterparts.

Dunphy J addressed the point of the sophistication of the plaintiff in the following paragraph:

[47] Once again, the plaintiff cites Machtinger (supra) in support of this argument. The plaintiff contends that only the clearest of waivers of the reasonable notice standard will suffice since absent such a bright line, employers may be tempted to attempt to cheat employees of their minimum ESA entitlements. Indeed, In Machtinger (supra), Iacobucci J. noted that many employees might not be aware that there is such a thing as minimum required notice and employment contracts may often involve a disparity in bargaining power. Such considerations are not in fact present here. The plaintiff is a well-educated individual. Far from reflecting a disparity of bargaining power, the employment agreement in this case represented a significant opportunity for the plaintiff to earn additional income based on a higher guaranteed base salary and a higher commission rate.

This was a motion for summary judgement. There is no mention at all in the judgement as to what education the plaintiff had . All we know is that he was a 68 year old Project Manager for a company that produced a ” glossy magazine ” ( para 8 of the judgement) .

Let us  assume that he finished high school , maybe even had a college degree in something. How does that make him so well educated that he is deemed to have knowledge of the entire ambit of Canadian employment law so that he would be able to ascertain which parts of his contract are valid, which are void and for those void provisions, what exactly are the new substituted provisions?

Employers write contracts because they don’t like the implied term of reasonable notice. I get it. Why however, should Courts allow employers to use convoluted language like in this case to spell out what they will pay upon termination? Why not simply require employers who want to limit their termination obligations to spell it out in clear terms without reference to complicated statutes that many lawyers do not fully understand ?

The Supreme Court of  Canada has now brought to the common law of  contracts, including employment contracts, the doctrine of honest dealing. Surely an important component of that duty is to draft termination provisions that are easy to read and comprehend for the average employee.

Employment contracts are not like agreements between large entities, each with a battery of lawyers to draft and review their agreements . They are much more like consumer contracts where fairness and clarity rule the day.

I am advised that this case is under appeal. I am hopeful that the Ontario Court of Appeal uses this case to give some enlightenment to this contentious and  difficult area of employment law.

 

969 thoughts on “Waiver and Severability Clause Cures All Defects in Employment Contract”

  1. Pingback: Best price viagra
  2. Pingback: cialis 5 mg
  3. Pingback: cialis daily cost
  4. Pingback: cyalis
  5. Pingback: cipro
  6. Pingback: cialis daily cost
  7. Pingback: cialis coupon
  8. Pingback: chloroquine otc
  9. Pingback: generic cialis
  10. Pingback: viagra substitute
  11. Pingback: viagra generic
  12. Pingback: viagra 50mg
  13. Pingback: viagra 100mg
  14. Pingback: otc ed pills
  15. Pingback: Buy cheap cialis
  16. Pingback: levitra usa
  17. Pingback: cheap levitra
  18. Pingback: free slots online
  19. Pingback: buy cialis 20mg
  20. Pingback: buy generic viagra
  21. Pingback: generic cialis
  22. Pingback: payday loans
  23. Pingback: cash payday
  24. Pingback: loans online
  25. Pingback: viagra for sale
  26. Pingback: cialis to buy
  27. Pingback: slot games online
  28. Pingback: bonus casino chips
  29. Pingback: 5 mg cialis
  30. Pingback: buy cialis
  31. Pingback: generic cialis
  32. Pingback: cialis 5 mg
  33. Pingback: free casino games
  34. Pingback: free slots online
  35. Pingback: slot games
  36. Pingback: purchase viagra
  37. Pingback: free viagra
  38. Pingback: viagra pills
  39. Pingback: buy tadalafil
  40. Pingback: cialis reviews
  41. Pingback: cialis pills
  42. Pingback: online gambling
  43. Pingback: slots real money
  44. Pingback: cialistodo.com
  45. Pingback: generic viagra
  46. Pingback: buy sildenafil
  47. Pingback: Viagra 50mg coupon
  48. Pingback: Viagra 50 mg nz
  49. Pingback: generic sildenafil
  50. Pingback: cialiss
  51. Pingback: buy Cialis 20 mg
  52. Pingback: Cialis 20mg tablet
  53. Pingback: generic viagra
  54. Pingback: order Cialis 40 mg
  55. Pingback: generic viagra
  56. Pingback: lexapro 5 mg usa
  57. Pingback: viagra dosage
  58. Pingback: actos 15mg otc
  59. Pingback: amaryl 4mg cheap
  60. Pingback: buy cialis
  61. Pingback: viagra
  62. Pingback: cialis online
  63. Pingback: cardizem 90 mg nz
  64. Pingback: casodex australia
  65. Pingback: cialis for sale
  66. Pingback: ceftin nz
  67. Pingback: celebrex usa
  68. Pingback: celexa 20 mg pills
  69. Pingback: natural ed pills
  70. Pingback: claritin 10 mg uk
  71. Pingback: buy viagra generic
  72. Pingback: best casino online
  73. Pingback: casino slots
  74. Pingback: casino world
  75. Pingback: ED Pills
  76. Pingback: gambling games
  77. Pingback: best casino online
  78. Pingback: best insurance car
  79. Pingback: generic cialis
  80. Pingback: buy cialis
  81. Pingback: buy cialis
  82. Pingback: payday loans
  83. Pingback: Viagra overnight
  84. Pingback: cialis
  85. Pingback: viagra online usa
  86. Pingback: 5mg cialis
  87. Pingback: cbd oil for dogs
  88. Pingback: cbd pure hemp oil
  89. Pingback: writers essay
  90. Pingback: my homework help
  91. Pingback: cleocin 300mg nz
  92. Pingback: viagra 12
  93. Pingback: clonidine online
  94. Pingback: clozaril 50 mg otc
  95. Pingback: Sample viagra
  96. Pingback: cialis generic uk
  97. Pingback: generic cialis
  98. Pingback: cozaar tablets
  99. Pingback: essayhelpbgs.com
  100. Pingback: buy viagra safely
  101. Pingback: dissertation help
  102. Pingback: cymbalta otc
  103. Pingback: cheap viagra
  104. Pingback: dapsone caps cost
  105. Pingback: cheapest differin
  106. Pingback: generic viagra
  107. Pingback: dramamine coupon
  108. Pingback: elavil 25mg online
  109. Pingback: Amoxil online
  110. Pingback: how to buy flomax
  111. Pingback: top ed pills
  112. Pingback: hyzaar cost
  113. Pingback: cialis order
  114. Pingback: imdur 20 mg uk
  115. Pingback: buy cialis
  116. Pingback: cialis 20mg
  117. Pingback: order imodium
  118. Pingback: natural viagra
  119. Pingback: imuran pills
  120. Pingback: lamisil generic
  121. Pingback: generic sildenafil
  122. Pingback: generic pills
  123. Pingback: cheap meclizine
  124. Pingback: viagra vs cyalus
  125. Pingback: micardis 20mg usa
  126. Pingback: pharmacy online
  127. Pingback: generic Zovirax
  128. Pingback: buy motrin 200mg
  129. Pingback: nortriptyline cost
  130. Pingback: viagra articles
  131. Pingback: prevacid online
  132. Pingback: prilosec 20mg cost
  133. Pingback: proair inhaler usa
  134. Pingback: buy cheap viagra
  135. Pingback: procardia 30mg uk
  136. Pingback: buy cheap viagra
  137. Pingback: proscar purchase
  138. Pingback: provigil usa
  139. Pingback: pulmicort otc
  140. Pingback: oregano antibiotic
  141. Pingback: zyrtec cream
  142. Pingback: buy retin-a cream
  143. Pingback: risperdal pharmacy
  144. Pingback: cost of robaxin
  145. Pingback: buy rogaine
  146. Pingback: cost of singulair
  147. Pingback: spiriva australia
  148. Pingback: tenormin 25 mg nz
  149. Pingback: toprol otc
  150. Pingback: tricor tablets
  151. Pingback: cheapest verapamil
  152. Pingback: original site
  153. Pingback: zithromax capsules
  154. Pingback: zyprexa nz
  155. Pingback: aripiprazole nz
  156. Pingback: glimepiride tablet
  157. Pingback: meclizine tablet
  158. Pingback: Google
  159. Pingback: leflunomide tablet
  160. Pingback: donepezil uk
  161. Pingback: irbesartan tablet
  162. Pingback: buy olmesartan
  163. Pingback: buspirone 10mg usa
  164. Pingback: cefuroxime otc
  165. Pingback: celecoxib purchase
  166. Pingback: cephalexin canada
  167. Pingback: cheap clozapine
  168. Pingback: mature porn
  169. Pingback: Japanese Porn Land
  170. Pingback: oxybutynin otc
  171. Pingback: langley plumber
  172. Pingback: cheapest bisacodyl
  173. Pingback: erythromycin price
  174. Pingback: Mining
  175. Pingback: xqzphzzn
  176. Pingback: Twink
  177. Pingback: estradiol canada
  178. Pingback: loxzfgar
  179. Pingback: buy alendronate
  180. Pingback: kratom for sale
  181. Pingback: wat is cialis
  182. Pingback: cheap glipizide
  183. Pingback: /40
  184. Pingback: 우리카지노
  185. Pingback: 퍼스트카지노
  186. Pingback: isosorbide nz
  187. Pingback: Buy Weed Online
  188. Pingback: generic omnicef
  189. Pingback: click here
  190. Pingback: best cbd oil
  191. Pingback: cbd oil
  192. Pingback: best cbd for dogs
  193. Pingback: best cbd for dogs
  194. Pingback: viagra
  195. Pingback: sex as exercise
  196. Pingback: sphynx cat
  197. Pingback: buy zyvox
  198. Pingback: indomethacin uk
  199. Pingback: cbd for sale
  200. Pingback: cialis 20mg usa
  201. Pingback: mba essay help
  202. Pingback: Gay Porn
  203. Pingback: merchants services
  204. Pingback: 샌즈카지노
  205. Pingback: 메리트카지노
  206. Pingback: 코인카지노
  207. Pingback: generic pills
  208. Pingback: Car Wash Kit
  209. Pingback: Pornhome
  210. Pingback: lasix diuretic
  211. Pingback: ventolin tabs 4mg
  212. Pingback: safestore auto
  213. Pingback: price of viagra
  214. Pingback: zithromax
  215. Pingback: safestore auto
  216. Pingback: price of viagra
  217. Pingback: cheap ed pills
  218. Pingback: Andre Nieri
  219. Pingback: Website agentur
  220. Pingback: thc vape juice
  221. Pingback: canadian me
  222. Pingback: crypto news
  223. Pingback: neurontin sleep
  224. Pingback: metformin for pcos
  225. Pingback: lexapro and paxil
  226. Pingback: plaquenil cpt code
  227. Pingback: viagra pills
  228. Pingback: multi coin bot
  229. Pingback: FLUSON 50ML
  230. Pingback: cost of clomid
  231. Pingback: crypto mining
  232. Pingback: canik tp9sfx
  233. Pingback: THC Cartridge
  234. Pingback: propecia prices
  235. Pingback: Surgical Gloves
  236. Pingback: the best ed pill
  237. Pingback: peyote
  238. Pingback: website
  239. Pingback: Zakhar Berkut hd
  240. Pingback: pharmacy websites
  241. Pingback: 4569987
  242. Pingback: write my essay
  243. Pingback: cialis 20 mg cost
  244. Pingback: buy drug
  245. Pingback: news news news
  246. Pingback: موقع سكس
  247. Pingback: best sex games
  248. Pingback: psy
  249. Pingback: psy2022
  250. Pingback: projectio-freid
  251. Pingback: SEO Agency
  252. Pingback: tinder uk review
  253. Pingback: kinoteatrzarya.ru
  254. Pingback: topvideos
  255. Pingback: video
  256. Pingback: about
  257. Pingback: nasstoys dildo
  258. Pingback: gas fireplace
  259. Pingback: prinivil 20mg tabs
  260. Pingback: Ukrainskie-serialy
  261. Pingback: site
  262. Pingback: top
  263. Pingback: Best Dildo
  264. Pingback: buy cialis now
  265. Pingback: vibrators
  266. Pingback: caluanie for sale
  267. Pingback: porn
  268. Pingback: first sex toys
  269. Pingback: visit website
  270. Pingback: cz scorpion evo 3
  271. Pingback: dental plans bc
  272. Pingback: clit sex toy
  273. Pingback: buy kratom
  274. Pingback: best sex toys
  275. Pingback: top erection pills
  276. Pingback: natural cialis gnc
  277. Pingback: sildenafil canada
  278. Pingback: best vibrators
  279. Pingback: Mail Gnfc In Login
  280. Pingback: buy kratom online
  281. Pingback: chelovek-iz-90-h
  282. Pingback: podolsk-region.ru
  283. Pingback: best delta 8
  284. Pingback: pump for ed
  285. Pingback: bender na4alo 2021
  286. Pingback: blogery_i_dorogi
  287. Pingback: Observer
  288. Pingback: ivermectin nz
  289. Pingback: bachelor's degree
  290. Pingback: plaquenil 300
  291. Pingback: pleasure kit
  292. Pingback: g-spot vibrator
  293. Pingback: BIG CHIEF EXTRACTS
  294. Pingback: Herald Net
  295. Pingback: dispensary near me
  296. Pingback: Seattle Weekly
  297. Pingback: weed
  298. Pingback: shroom chocolate
  299. Pingback: tiktok followers
  300. Pingback: Data obligasi
  301. Pingback: Restaurants
  302. Pingback: remedies for ed
  303. Pingback: MILF Porn Land
  304. Pingback: chernaya vodova
  305. Pingback: 66181
  306. Pingback: istanbul escort
  307. Pingback: rus escort
  308. Pingback: Parksville Roofers
  309. Pingback: boho coffee table
  310. Pingback: Sig Romeo 5
  311. Pingback: Porno
  312. Pingback: vechernyy urgant
  313. Pingback: ukraine
  314. Pingback: Running Machine
  315. Pingback: mexican viagra
  316. Pingback: A3ixW7AS
  317. Pingback: insulated shed
  318. Pingback: buy cialis now
  319. Pingback: adam and eve
  320. Pingback: mp3juices download
  321. Pingback: Find out more
  322. Pingback: software reviewer
  323. Pingback: Discreet gun shop
  324. Pingback: aqua juul
  325. Pingback: link
  326. Pingback: glo carts for sale
  327. Pingback: KremlinTeam
  328. Pingback: medunitsa.ru
  329. Pingback: kremlin-team.ru
  330. Pingback: psychophysics.ru
  331. Pingback: yesmail.ru
  332. Pingback: trauma recovery
  333. Pingback: Suicide Squad 2
  334. Pingback: pc support
  335. Pingback: read more
  336. Pingback: psiholog
  337. Pingback: male strokers
  338. Pingback: butterfly sex toy
  339. Pingback: erotica audio
  340. Pingback: sariyer escort
  341. Pingback: phuket sandbox
  342. Pingback: regcialist.com
  343. Pingback: happyluke
  344. Pingback: pocket pussy
  345. Pingback: toys for men
  346. Pingback: sariyer escort
  347. Pingback: elit escort
  348. Pingback: sultanbeyli escort
  349. Pingback: happyruck.com
  350. Pingback: ben wa balls
  351. Pingback: best sex toys
  352. Pingback: mersin escort
  353. Pingback: stromectol generic
  354. Pingback: buy weed uk
  355. Pingback: plaquenil cheapest
  356. Pingback: Asian Restaurant
  357. Pingback: fun88
  358. Pingback: prostate massage
  359. Pingback: prostate toy
  360. Pingback: service in canada
  361. Pingback: hosting deals
  362. Pingback: pocket stroker
  363. Pingback: ارقامك
  364. Pingback: bostanci escort
  365. Pingback: 99defi p2p network
  366. Pingback: site de streaming
  367. Pingback: site de streaming
  368. Pingback: film streaming
  369. Pingback: pocket vagina
  370. Pingback: sex toy reviews
  371. Pingback: w888
  372. Pingback: male stroker
  373. Pingback: best in ottawa
  374. Pingback: magic mushrooms
  375. Pingback: 메이저사이트
  376. Pingback: 피망머니상
  377. Pingback: ivermectin
  378. Pingback: viagra alternative
  379. Pingback: herbal viagra
  380. Pingback: viagra generic
  381. Pingback: syoss
  382. Pingback: cialis by mail
  383. Pingback: ed pharmacy
  384. Pingback: cheap cialis
  385. Pingback: cialis canada
  386. Pingback: Duna 2021
  387. Pingback: about
  388. Pingback: viagra online usa
  389. Pingback: male sex toy
  390. Pingback: viagra canada
  391. Pingback: mp3 juice download
  392. Pingback: viagra cost canada
  393. Pingback: Livestock for sale
  394. Pingback: ivermectin cost
  395. Pingback: best male sex toys
  396. Pingback: online doxycycline
  397. Pingback: viagra online
  398. Pingback: 40 mg cialis
  399. Pingback: cialis free canada
  400. Pingback: otc viagra usa
  401. Pingback: web sajtovi
  402. Pingback: lowes kronos
  403. Pingback: viagra otc
  404. Pingback: buy Ventolin
  405. Pingback: bolton viagra
  406. Pingback: taurus gx4
  407. Pingback: pdx1 12 defender
  408. Pingback: sig p320x carry
  409. Pingback: walther ccp m2 9mm
  410. Pingback: cost of tadalafil
  411. Pingback: magic mushrooms
  412. Pingback: z pak for uti
  413. Pingback: sildenafil buy
  414. Pingback: cheap pills online
  415. Pingback: sildenafil 20 mg
  416. Pingback: buy juul online
  417. Pingback: Thc vape juice
  418. Pingback: 3080 ftw3 msrp
  419. Pingback: nolvadex pills

Leave a Reply